By Ardena Perry
Animal welfare is a sensitive subject. Most people want to do the right thing; we just can't agree on what that is.
There are "no kill" advocates who believe life at any cost is acceptable. Many of us find that appalling, knowing that animals become less adoptable and suffer mentally with prolonged kenneling -- isolation from others, chaos, despondency. A dog does not know if it is in the county facility, the Humane Society or a puppy mill; the kennels are the same -- rows of barking dogs in concrete runs with chain link gates. In the county facility the stay is short; in the Humane Society it can go for months, until the animals go kennel crazy or develop health problems that go with extended confinement.
We face hard choices: euthanasia or life behind bars. Neither is something we would pick for the cute puppy of just a few months ago, so can we agree that neither is "humane" and meet somewhere in the middle, putting what is best for both spirit and body of our companion animals first.
From January until Sept. 18, there were 167 dogs and
221 cats, all healthy, all adoptable, euthanized at Washoe County Regional Animal Services. They were killed because the Humane Society was full of long-term residents. The contract that was agreed to when we built this regional facility was that WCRAS would take in all strays, and Nevada Humane Society would transfer animals from WCRAS and be responsible for all adoptions. Former pets leave Animal Control in only four ways: redemption, rescue, euthanasia or transfer to NHS.
When the Humane Society pursues a "no kill" policy, it becomes overcrowded, and animals are not transferred from the county side without an adoption hold. Five days to live or die, based on space, nothing more, while Humane Society animals languish for many months before a rescue group takes them, so they are kenneled in a different location, but nonetheless, kenneled.
From January to August, there were 252 dogs taken by rescue groups. I commend their effort. However, transferring the problem is not solving it. Owner surrenders now are being asked to come back, so that portion of the NHS contract is being sidestepped, and still animals are warehoused while others die, without being seen. From my determinations, the recidivism rate is about 10 percent. Storing animals is cruel; it is demoralizing to be returned and readopted, and returned.
The Nevada Humane Society was built with the funding of George Whittell in the spirit of the Humane Society of the United States. That money rolled over into the current facility. The agenda of the no-kill advocacy, based in California, is not feasible in Washoe County. It was never the intention of the voters to circumvent his intentions.
Let Animal Control handle adoptions. Keep the Humane Society as we voted for it.
Ardena Perry lives in Sparks.


